Brixham, United Kingdom – On the dockside in Brixham, a bustling fishing port in southwest England, the fear is that Britain’s departure from the European Union may prove a false dawn for hopes of taking back control.
The area voted 63 percent in favour of leaving the EU in the 2016 referendum — a sign of the anger over its fishing quotas and equal access rights blamed for a long-term decline of the industry.
But with exactly one year to go from Thursday before Britain’s scheduled departure date, fishermen see signs that their concerns could be traded away in negotiations with Brussels.
“Fishermen have never had a good deal in all the years I can remember,” said Dave Banks, 69, who had just returned from four days at sea, catching cuttlefish, sole and turbot in nearby waters as skipper of the 24-metre (78-foot) trawler, Stephanie.
In a draft agreement published this month, the government conceded that Britain would effectively remain part of the EU fisheries policy during a 20-month transition period following its formal departure on March 29 next year.
The concession has sparked outcry from fishermen and staunch Brexit supporters who last week staged a protest on the River Thames.
– ‘Absolutely sick’ –
Meanwhile, what happens beyond 2021 is still to be negotiated.
“It makes me absolutely sick,” said Rick Smith, a retired fisherman and chairman of Brixham Trawler Agents, which among other roles runs the town’s daily fish auction, calling the move “an appeasement”.
“We hope that we’re going to make enough noise to not allow it. But it depends on the strength of our politicians and if they’re weak, and they start caving in to European demands,” he said from the firm’s office overlooking the port.
Britain’s fishing industry has been shrinking for decades, due to economic as well as political factors.
After years of EU quotas that limited what boats can catch in waters currently shared with other European vessels, many fishermen left the industry.
The British government also scrapped boats during the 2000s to try to help ensure sustainable fish stocks, and redirected financially stretched fishermen to other work.
“So many boats have gone against the wall because of the quotas,” said Banks, as he stood on the boat’s bridge and directed a small crane lifting crates of fish out from its depths.
“It’s absolutely disgusting the way British fishermen have been treated over the last 40 years.”
Fishermen in Brixham and elsewhere bemoan the sale of UK-registered vessels to foreign owners, which then fish from the British quota but land their catch abroad.
They believe quotas are unfairly weighted in favour of the Europeans and together with the access granted to British waters, have combined to doom the industry.
Environmentalists argue quotas have been effective in replenishing heavily-depleted stocks, with North Sea cod stocks now at 35-year highs.
Cod, a long-time favourite of British fish ‘n’ chip shops, riles fishermen in southwestern ports like Brixham.
The 2016 quota for the English Channel gave French boats 72 percent of the stocks, and Britain just nine percent.
Although the UK makes up for it in the North Sea, where it holds over half the quota, the policy seems nonsensical to those in Brixham.
– ‘Catch what you like’ –
The town, on what locals call the English Riviera, has fierce pride in its heritage and is now England’s biggest port by landed fish value.
At a daily dawn market, where auctioneers in white coats flog fish by the kilo to dozens of wholesalers and local retailers amid the chorus of seagulls, over 40 species are sold.
Sheltered by steep hills packed with narrow streets and colourfully painted houses, the harbour dominates daily life.
Even on a dreary day in March, plenty of visitors could be see sampling the town’s seafood restaurants, while weather-beaten fishermen clocking off headed to the port’s nearest pub, The Crown & Anchor.
Andrew McLeod, 49, who captains the 33.5-metre Van Dijck trawler, has spent three decades navigating the ups and downs of the industry, and six months ago welcomed his 19-year-old son aboard.
“Back in the day you could go catch what you like, land what you like,” he recalled.
The father-of-five, whose father was a master mariner in the merchant navy but bought a fishing boat to avoid being away most of the year, speaks for many when he said he fears the industry being used as a “bargaining chip” in Brexit negotiations.
The fishing industry represents just 0.4 percent of Britain’s GDP, according to 2016 statistics.
“In the grand scheme of things it’s probably not that valuable but it is to communities, especially like Brixham,” said Smith.
“Brixham is fishing — if we’ve not got fishing here, there’s not a lot else.”
Sarah Wollaston, the Conservative Member of Parliament for Brixham, told AFP: “Britain’s fishing industry undoubtedly had a bad deal when we entered the EEC (European Economic Community).
“It will cause a huge amount of resentment if fairness is not restored as part of our leaving the European Union.”
By Joe Jackson